I’ve covered the impact that automated detection systems have on false positives in the past. Hispasec, the makers of VirusTotal, also talked about this issue in their blog post aptly named Antivirus Rumorology. More recently Kaspersky conducted an experiment during a press conference and showed a bunch of journalists how these false positives roll over from one vendor engine to the next. Of course being journalists, they only took home the message “AV copies each other and mostly us” as is shown in the articles published covering the event . Even though the objective of the experiment was put under scrutiny, the fact remains that this is an industry-wide problem and no single vendor is immune to its effects, not even Kaspersky as we will see.
‘Usability’ tests the product's ability to perform without disturbance despite false positives and other internet-related security issues. ChyangKyu Han, Head of AhnLab Security Emergency Response Center (ASEC) said, “V3 is acknowledged an industry-leading anti-malware product for both business and home users. The current test AhnLab V3 Mobile Security 3.1 for Android (191801) from May 2019 of AV-TEST, the leading international and independent service provider for antivirus software and malware.
If it is indeed a false positive. How to report it to avast! And what to do to exclude them until the problem is corrected. AhnLab-V3 2008.9.3.0 2008.09.02. VirusTotal is not responsible for false positives generated by any of the resources it uses. False positive issues should be addressed directly with the company or individual behind the product under consideration. Antivirus products. Acronis (Acronis) AegisLab (AegisLab) Agnitum (Agnitum) AhnLab (V3) Alibaba Group (Alibaba) Antiy Labs (Antiy-AVL). On-Demand Test – Ahnlab V3 IS 8.0 – August 2011 www.av-comparatives.org – 3 - Tested product We tested the Ahnlab V3 IS 8.0 product with last signature update of the 12th August 2011. On-Demand Test-Set The used test-set contains about 206000 malware samples from the last six month which have been.
As some of the regular readers of this blog will probably remember, in March 2010 we published a “PandaCloudTestFile.exe” binary file to test the connectivity of Panda products with its cloud-scanning component, Collective Intelligence. This “PandaCloudTestFile.exe” is a completely harmless file that only tells the Panda products to query the cloud. Our cloud-scanning servers have been manually configured to detect this file as malicious with the only objective of showing the end user that the cloud-scanning component of his/her product are working correctly.
Initially this file was only detected by Panda as Trj/CI.A (a Collective Intelligence detection) and Symantec’s Insight (noting that this is not a very common file, even though treating reputation alone as “suspicious” is by itself grounds enough for debate — maybe another future post).
Panda 10.0.2.2 2010.03.10 Trj/CI.A
Symantec 20091.2.0.41 2010.03.11 Suspicious.Insight
A few days later came the first problematic detection, this time from Kaspersky, who detected the “PandaCloudTestFile.exe” with a signature, specifically calling it a Bredolab backdoor. I call this detection problematic as it is clearly not a suspicious detection nor a reputation signature. It is also clearly an incorrect detection as the file in itself is not related in any way to Bredolab. Soon we will see why this Kaspersky signature is problematic.
Kaspersky 7.0.0.125 2010.03.20 Backdoor.Win32.Bredolab.djl
In the next few days some other AV scanners started detecting it as well, in many cases with the exact same Bredolab name.
McAfee+Artemis 5930 2010.03.24 Artemis!E01A57998BC1
Fortinet 4.0.14.0 2010.03.26 W32/Bredolab.DJL!tr.bdr
TheHacker 6.5.2.0.245 2010.03.26 Backdoor/Bredolab.dmb
Antiy-AVL 2.0.3.7 2010.03.31 Backdoor/Win32.Bredolab.gen
Jiangmin 13.0.900 2010.03.31 Backdoor/Bredolab.bmr
VBA32 3.12.12.4 2010.03.31 Backdoor.Win32.Bredolab.dmb
In the month that follows (April 2010) a bunch of new engines started detecting it, mostly as the Bredolab name we are now familiar with, although some new names started appearing as well (Backdoor.generic, Monder, Trojan.Generic, etc.).
a-squared 4.5.0.50 2010.04.05 Trojan.Win32.Bredolab!IK
AhnLab-V3 2010.04.30.00 2010.04.30 Backdoor/Win32.Bredolab
AVG 9.0.0.787 2010.04.30 BackDoor.Generic12.BHAD
Ikarus T3.1.1.80.0 2010.04.05 Trojan.Win32.Bredolab
CAT-QuickHeal 10.00 2010.04.12 Backdoor.Bredolab.djl
TrendMicro 9.120.0.1004 2010.04.03 TROJ_MONDER.AET
Sunbelt 6203 2010.04.21 Trojan.Win32.Generic!BT
VBA32 3.12.12.4 2010.04.02 Backdoor.Win32.Bredolab.dmb
VirusBuster 5.0.27.0 2010.04.17 Backdoor.Bredolab.BLU
And to top it all off, during this month of May 2010 the following engines started detecting “PandaCloudTestFile.exe” as well. Here we can also even see a “suspicious” detection, probably the only one out of all of them that could make any sense.
Authentium 5.2.0.5 2010.05.15 W32/Backdoor2.GXIM
F-Prot 4.5.1.85 2010.05.15 W32/Backdoor2.GXIM
McAfee 5.400.0.1158 2010.05.05 Bredolab!j
McAfee-GW-Edition 2010.1 2010.05.05 Bredolab!j
Norman 6.04.12 2010.05.13 W32/Suspicious_Gen3.CUGF
PCTools 7.0.3.5 2010.05.14 Backdoor.Bredolab
TrendMicro-HouseCall 9.120.0.1004 2010.05.05 TROJ_MONDER.AET
ViRobot 2010.5.4.2303 2010.05.05 Backdoor.Win32.Bredolab.40960.K
It is worth noting that consumer products have other technologies included in their products, such as white-listing and digital certificate checks, which could cause the file to not be detected on the consumer endpoint, but the fact that there is a signature for such file is a good indicator that it will probably be detected on the endpoint.
So why am I writing about all this? First of all, to emphasize the point I tried to make in the past that automated systems have to be maintained, monitored, tuned and improved so that more in-depth analysis is done through them and not rely so much on “rumorology”.
Secondly, to show that this is an industry-wide problematic that results from having to deal with tens of thousands of new malware variants per day, and no vendor is immune to it. What matters at the end of the day is that the automated systems are supervised and improved constantly to avoid false positives.
I can certainly understand why vendors point to their signatures being “rolled over” to other AV engines, but these same vendors should also take care so that they do not become the source of these “false positive rumors” in the first place.
UPDATE June 3rd, 2010: Reading Larry’s post over at securitywatch, it seems Kaspersky has reacted quickly and has removed their signature for the PandaCloudTestFile.exe file. Thanks Larry & Kaspersky!
Security Upgrade for EveryoneALYac Enterprise is a total security program which securely protects your system by
scanning and cleaning viruses and malware, through real-time scanning features.
Ahnlab V3 Report False Positive Results
Product Overview
Security Upgrade for Everyone
ALYac Enterprise
- 01 Employeed Triple Engines
Uses Tera Engine(developed by ESTSecurity), Bitdefender Engine
Powerful detection of malicious codes
- 02 Less resource utilization through engine optimization and weight lightening
Optimized Scanning Engine
Less resource utilization through weight lightening
- 03 Smart Scanning and Minimizing False Positive
Fast and efficient scanning based on the white list
Fast scanning time
Minimize false positives by using various criteria
- 04 Various OS Support
Full support for 64bit OS
Full support for Windows 10
Product UI
Main Features
Quick and Accurate Malware Detection
Malware Scanning and Cleaning
Cleans not only the virus, but also various types of malware such as spyware, rootkit, and trojan
Easy scanning by one-click
Enable situational scanning through Quick Scan and Advanced Scan
Real-time Monitoring
Real-time Monitoring and Defending of Malwares 24/7
Proactive disinfection for malicious bots
Real-time scan and clean when USB is connected
Automated Update
3 Regular updates everyday
emergency updates
Effective response to malicious code through latest DB
Ransomware Blocking Feature
Detect and block major ransomwares
Blocks unknown ransomwares with behavior-based detection
Collect suspicious ransomware files and enhance DB
Isloation and restoration of detected and cleaned files
Quarantine detected and cleaned files
Quarantine files by selected period or file size
Storing period at Quarantine section can be set and changed by user
Restoring deleted files can be done in the Quarantine section
Various Additional Features
PC optimization and management
Support Game Mode
Laptop power saving
Security Statistics
Host file protection
Environment
ALYac Enterprise Specs
Ahnlab V3 Lite
Minimum Specification: 500MHz or higher
Recommanded Specification: 2GHz or higher
Minimum Specification: 1GB or higher
Recommanded Specification: 2GB or higher
Minimum Specification: 800MB or more free space
Recommanded Specification: 1GB or more free space
Microsoft Windows XP SP3 or higher / Vista SP1 or higher / 7 / 8 / 8.1 / 10 (32bit & 64bit)
Comments are closed.